Meat Church Reviews
Meat Church has an overall rating of 4.0 based on 48 reviews. Customer feedback on Meat Church is mixed: Meat Church reviewers highlight positive aspects like high-quality meats, excellent customer service, diverse product selection, competitive pricing, which strongly appeal to meat enthusiasts, home cooks, barbecue lovers, gourmet food shoppers. However, Meat Church is often criticized for its shipping delays, limited local availability, higher price point for some items, occasional stock issues.
48 reviews
5 Stars
8
4 Stars
6
3 Stars
5
2 Stars
0
1 Star
1
How would you rate Meat Church?
All Meat Church Reviews (48)
michael1985
May 12, 2026
"Rub didn’t stick like I hoped"
I was a little disappointed with this rub. I patted the meat dry and tried to apply it evenly, but it still didn’t really stick well and a good amount fell off before I even got it onto the smoker. The flavor was okay, but it’s hard to judge when so much of it doesn’t stay on. I also wish the instructions were a bit clearer about how to get it to adhere better, because I felt like I was guessing. Probably not one I’d buy again.
0
Reply
HOFFMAN
May 12, 2026
"Box was a little banged up, but all good"
The box showed up with a bit of a dent, which had me slightly worried at first, but everything inside was still sealed and totally fine. No issues with the actual product at all. I do think a little extra padding would probably help, though
0
Reply
heather1996
May 11, 2026
"Good rub, annoying lid"
The rub itself is really good, so in my head it passed the “would I buy this again?” test quickly. But the lid/container situation is kind of a pain. It gets messy fast, and every time I use it I’m reminded why I usually judge seasoning containers by how easy they are to open and keep clean
0
Reply
PeggyPeters
May 11, 2026
"There are a ton of seasoning options…"
There are a ton of seasoning options, which is great, though it took me a bit longer than I would’ve liked to sort through everything. That said, I did end up finding a few new favorites that worked really well on ribs and chicken, so I can’t complain too much.
0
Reply
hello_dale302
April 22, 2026
"Everything came just right"
I got exactly what I ordered, and there wasn’t nothing missing or mixed up. Simple, but that’s all I was hoping for.
0
Reply
BillieJacobs_58
April 17, 2026
"Nice shirts, I probably should’ve sized up"
I ordered a couple shirts from meatchurch.com they showed up looking really good. The material feels nice and not cheap or too thin, and the print held up fine after I washed them. The fit is true to size overall, but they were a little snug in the shoulders on me. I’ll put that partly on myself because I probably should’ve known to size up if I wanted a more relaxed fit. Still happy with them, just wish the sizing had a bit more room.
0
Reply
ruby_Landry97
April 17, 2026
"Great texture, but I was a little skeptical"
I’ll be honest, I was kind of suspicious at first because a lot of rubs either turn out way too powdery or have big chunky bits that don’t spread right. But this one actually has a really nice grind. It sticks to the meat well and goes on easy without clumping up. I used it on ribs and chicken, and both came out nice. Definitely better than I expected...
0
Reply
Rosario_wheeler91
April 08, 2026
"Clear ingredient info, just a bit small"
I like that the ingredients are easy to find and straightforward to read. My only complaint is that I wish the details were printed a little bigger. Overall, I’d say it’s helpful and clear enough for me.
0
Reply
lavonyann8487
March 22, 2026
"Surprisingly, they had what I needed"
I wasn’t really expecting much, but I checked for a few rubs and they actually had everything in stock. Checkout was quick and easy too, with no waiting around or annoying out-of-stock surprises. Hard to complain, honestly.
0
Reply
Amber_womack01
February 21, 2026
"Found it nearby for a decent price"
I was able to find it easily at my local store, which was nice. I’m usually mindful of price, so I was glad I didn’t have to shop around too much or pay extra just to get it
0
Reply
PamelaFerguson_08
January 27, 2026
"Good brand, but the experience felt a little underwhelming"
I’ve always heard good things about Meat Church, and I still think they’re a solid, trusted brand overall. My experience just wasn’t anything special. It wasn’t bad, but with their reputation, I expected a little more. What bothered me most was getting one of those canned apology responses that feels like it was copied and pasted instead of someone actually listening. Not a terrible experience, just kind of disappointing.
0
Reply
joseph-Shouse
January 15, 2026
"Still the same really great rub every time"
I’ve ordered this a bunch of times now, and it’s always just as good. The flavor is really consistent, tastes great every time, and I’ve never had any issues with it.
0
Reply
JONES
January 06, 2026
"I tried two of the recipes…"
I tried two of the recipes and both turned out good overall. They were easy enough to follow and the end results were tasty, which I appreciated. That said, I do think a little more detail in the instructions would have helped in a few spots, especially for timing and texture. Still, I’d definitely try more recipes from this.
0
Reply
victoria1980
January 05, 2026
"Actually tastes really good"
I wasn’t totally sure what to expect, but yeah... this tastes great. Like, genuinely good. And the best part is there’s no weird aftertaste, which is usually the thing that bothers me with stuff like this. I’d definitely get it again.
0
Reply
hello_iris233
December 29, 2025
"Some of the items tasted pretty…"
Some of the items tasted fresh, which I appreciated, but a couple seemed like they’d been sitting around a little too long. It wasn’t awful by any means, just kind of mixed. For what I paid, I was hoping everything would taste a bit more consistently fresh
0
Reply
alfonso1981
December 29, 2025
"Tasty, but a little pricey"
The seasonings were good and shipping was totally fine, no issues there. I really liked the flavor, but the bags feel a bit expensive for how quickly I go through them lol. I’d probably buy again if there’s a sale, but at full price I’m not sure it’s the best value for me righ tnow
0
Reply
hello_steve446
December 27, 2025
"I used Meat Church seasoning on some..."
I used Meat Church seasoning on some ribs and chicken this weekend, for that kind of cook, it worked really well. The rub stuck nicely, didn’t burn up on the grill, and the flavor came through without being overly salty. My family even pointed out that everything tasted better than usual, which is usually how I know something actually made a difference. I’m not saying it’s the only seasoning I’ll ever use, but for ribs and chicken, I’ll definitely be reaching for it again.
0
Reply
robertoneal6963
December 26, 2025
"Good products, but support was a little slow"
I ordered from Meat Church and the products themselves were totally fine, no complaints there. I did have a question for customer service, though, and it took a bit longer than I expected to get a reply 😕. They did eventually get back to me and were helpful, so it wasn’t a bad experience overall. Just wish the response time had been a little quicker.
0
Reply
Florence_vogler82
December 21, 2025
"It showed up fast, which…"
It showed up fast, which was a nice surprise. No complaints from me!
0
Reply
richardkibby6518
December 01, 2025
"Ordering Was Simple"
Ordering was super easy, which is all you really want when buying something online. No confusing steps or hassle, just straightforward and quick.
0
Reply
Have a question about Meat Church?
Log in to ask your Meat Church question!
Customer Reviews
Ask a Question
